It was very “grey man” and worked great for years, but eventually the velcro wore out.
In search of the better mouse trap, I tried the magnetic clip on route thinking I would be quicker if I didn’t have to lift the now worn out velcro flap:
I have a couple of these for a few different models, they can be bulky and tie up a pocket but they are durable because most of these I have had for 5 years.
I’m using NeoMag Holder, the magnetic one you didn’t like.
I’m my case it the best concealment and fastest access to spare mag.
It requires a little adjustment how the mag is grabbed from the packet, comparing to regular holders, but still this one is the most convenient for me.
I have one of those for my 9mm (only carry occasionally). Although it works well to protect the magazine, it takes two hands to get the mag out. This is why I am happy with the Galco pocket magazine holster as a non belt option.