Does a disability give you special rights?

You don’t have special rights, but then again, I’m pretty sure intruders/criminals don’t broadcast whose house they are planning on breaking into. In addition, given this Chinese virus thing, the criminals will be released immediately.

4 Likes

You too!
I’m just glad to live in TN. If you saw the movie “Shooter” with Mark Wahlburg (Swagger) he went to Athens, .TN and said to Michael Pena (Memphis) " Welcome to Tennesse, the patrons state of shooting stuff". I thought that was awesome, and it’s true!

4 Likes

True Patrick, about home intrusion. I’ve got that covered living in an apartment with an alarm system. It’s going to the doctor, dentist, grocery store, etc. that concerns me.

4 Likes

Understood.

3 Likes

Thanks OldGnome,
This forum is great, at least I call it a forum lol.
With gun laws and the Second Amendment under constant attack, who knows what tomorrow will bring.
Right now the pandemic will change the world forever.

3 Likes

That is certain.

3 Likes

I like the term “what ever it takes to stop the threat.”

4 Likes

I have a stun gun, police grade mace, a baton, and several carry pistols. I don’t carry all of them at the same time, but close. Here in Chattanooga several people were leaving grocery stores and were robbed in the parking lot while going to their cars. Not for money, toilet paper. Go figure.

3 Likes

I am a mess physically, I have a fusion of my complete lumbar from L1- thru S-2. Plus several other life altering issues. My hope is that my attorney is good enough to build a reasonable man that is like me.

That is the legal standard is what would a “reasonable” person who is just like you, what would they have done.

3 Likes

@Simjack OOOHhhh you got a Bock cage and Omiron implants. I used to do that for a living. Yes they suck sorry but they were the best game in town at the time and beat the hell out the alternatives. IMHO I would trade your Trump hat in for a nice fishing hat, keep your shooting irons handy but not out loud and carry on (think Grey Man on wheels)

A song comes to mind “I ain’t as good as I once was, but I’m as good once, as I ever was…” I’d rather be flat on my face alive than flat on my back dead. Of course there are worse things than dying.

Cheers,

Craig6

6 Likes

I agree with the others. You get no special privileges because of a handicap but physical capabilities will play into any self defense scenario.
I also agree that what you wear should be considered if you want to avoid a negative encounter.
Finally, you can go to jail or court. Transportation will be provided.

3 Likes

Your ‘disability’ is nothing compared to many. In the eyes of the law you get no breaks.

I have a gal who comes to the range to shoot and she is wheelchair-bound. She was actually shot by a former boyfriend. I’m impressed with her resolve to never be a victim again.

Personally, I am fused from T10 to L3 and from L4 to S1. (Burst fractures). And no, I don’t set off the detectors, despite a heck of a lot of titanium. Believe it or not, the lower back injuries you have are becoming quite common in people over 55 years of age. It’s an area that begins to show aging by age 25!

2 Likes

I have PTSD, was in Saigon, saw atrocities that I have still have nightmares about. My disability is something to me.

4 Likes

@Simjack - I don’t think anyone has been denying your disability, just noting that from a personal defense perspective, it doesn’t give you any special rights.

2 Likes

No one is making light of your disability. We are just saying it doesn’t give a special standing under the law.

Where your disability would come into play is in the courtroom. One of the standards to convict is what would a reasonable person who WAS just like you have done. That’s where your attorney would bring in your disabilities and diminished physical capacity.

For example, my reasonable man has a 6 level fusion of the lumbar spine, both hips replaced, both SI joints fused, an extremely rare medical condition for stress and an implanted Nevro unit (helps me walk).

That doesn’t give me special standing to not get arrested and brought to trial but can be used as mitigating circumstances for why I acted in self defense the way that I did.

As one final note I am assuming from the Saigon mention, you were in Vietnam, thank you for your service. I think our nation treated our Vietnam servicemen shamefully.

6 Likes

Here in Louisiana, a disability [diagnosis of any-kind at any age]would give you special privileges to have a doctor consent you firearms permit… [Sarcastic tone]

In all truth, I’m fighting for people’s rights concerning that. It’s unconstitutional and many flaws exist on this b/s legislation. But I’ll name two for time sake,

(1) DOCTORS FEEL THEY ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR PATIENTS POTENTIALLY MIS-HANDLING AND[or] RESULTING IN BODILY HARM, AND[or] DEATH AFTER COMPLETION! This miscommunication causes attorneys to advise for them NOT to sign off on this mandatory form[On your part…They DO NOT have to submit AND most likely will NOT.

FYI: Any individual who misrepresents any medical diagnosis or medicines that a doctor must verify is committing a felony. Therefore, I don’t suggest any thinking they left-out or forgot your ADHD diagnosis age 11 causing you to be arrested.

(2) Doctors for Responsible Gun Owners did not help me find a doctor therefore, I would not count on them for anybody else here in Louisiana.

1 Like

Tennessee doesn’t have those types of restrictions. Until your post I haven’t heard of those restrictions but Tennessee is a A2 state. On the surface Louisiana sounds like their legistrators are imposing strict gun control measures.

2 Likes

This has actually been in affect sense 2014 but issue is, recent diagnosis…

Not mentally insain, I’m not taking narcotics but issue remains in law…

I’m too honest of person…

1 Like

@Simjack
Hello. I’m late replying, and haven’t read all of the replies before mine. However, I read enough to see the great folks point out and link to data about disparity of force.

Lemme tell you what the prosecuting attorney who taught a legal update class I took a few years after having been licensed to carry in Ohio.

Because I have a medicine pump with more than enough medicine in it to kill me, if an attack of any physical nature threatened that pump being damaged and overdosing me, which I later verified with my Dr is precisely what would happen, he said I am legally permitted to respond to an attack as quickly, under the laws of our state, as would someone in a wheelchair. The fact is, a punch to the stomach or being knocked down hard enough, in my case is a deadly threat.

EDIT–Add this: “special RIGHTS?” NO.
Special consideration in a court of law by a jury, and soundly presented by your defense attorney? Yes, I think probably.

What I’m getting at is that each individual is by definition, different. So what constitutes “Imminent danger of severe bodily harm or death,” which is my Ohio criteria for using lethal force in self-defense, will be interpreted with such things as disabilities in mind, given your defense is aware and worth a whit. But since u r posting here, you must have defense shield and if u ever need an attorney, the USCCA is going to make sure you have one qualified to defend you…at least i bet on thst proposition with monthly dues…

4 Likes

from one vet to another “WELCOME HOME”