Question for the Pros

My question is as a new member to the CC community, I am looking for direction with regards to situational things in the public. I frequent my local WAWA daily (convenient store in PA) and my area in general appears to have several permit carry law abiding citizens and I wanted to know if I am in this store at a time of a robbery what are my options? and what does the threat to me mean as I may not be the intended person in danger. What are my obligations in this situation? please give feedback.

Thank yo in advance,

1 Like

Welcome to the Community, @Michael23!

You have a lot of options and aren’t obligated to intervene as you are not a law enforcement officer.

If you can get out safely, that is always an option.

If you feel like you are in imminent danger of death or grave bodily harm, you can use lethal force to defend yourself in most states.

If others are in imminent danger of death or grave bodily harm, you can use lethal force to defend them in a lot of states. A lot of states allow for the defense of a 3rd party who is innocent (if you come upon two people fighting and you don’t know who started it or what is going on, be a good witness).

This new blog post by Kevin Michalowski may help you think through some of the options. It’s a different location, but the article will give you points to think about:

Here are the specific carry laws for Pennsylvania for your reference:

Anyone else have suggestions for @Michael23?

3 Likes

Thank you Dawn.

1 Like

Great answer Dawn.

1 Like

My rule of thumb is self preservation then worry about others.

Check laws USCCA has great information on states laws.
If you can take a credible class specific to your states laws. Something more detailed and focused then a basic CCW course.

1 Like

Being armed doesn’t imbue you with any special obligations.

If there is a deadly threat to yourself or others you have one more option available to you to deal with it than you’d have if you were not armed.

The best advice I can give is to just be sure not to escalate the situation unnecessarily, be the best witness you can be and avoid putting yourself or others in any greater danger.

If you have an obligation it is a moral obligation to first protect your loved ones, yourself, and to make sure you go go home to your family when it’s over.

If you’re not directly involved understand that by stepping into any third party encounter you put yourself at great risk and even if you know the people involved you’re going into it with only partial information.

2 Likes

Ask yourself these three questions:

  1. Can I retreat?
  2. Am I in danger of great bodily injury or death?
  3. Is the force you choose to use more than you needed to stop the threat?

Answers:

  1. Yes, depending on state you may have a duty to retreat if you can.
  2. Yes, you do what you need to do to prevent injury or death.
  3. Yes, find another defense option or simply be a very good witness.

Number three is tricky for several reasons, the main one depending on the weapon used deadly force may or may not be justified.

For instance if you’re maced, drawing and shooting could be justified based on the next actions of the subject. Are they now physically attacking you? Have you pinned to the ground, against a wall or …

The problem with addressing scenarios like this is that there are too many variables that may come into play. What may be justified in one state may put you on trial in another. What I do with these scenarios is answer from my gut and than check my state laws to see how my gut reaction is aligned with the law.

1 Like

I suggest you view the videos on here. I believe Dawn you were in one for this very situation yes?

1 Like

Linking @Dawn so it will pop up on her radar.

I was, @Raymond! It was an amazing experience! (Thanks for the tag @Zee)

The Proving Ground training I was a part of was a convenience store robbery. The first scenario he had a knife but couldn’t reach the cashier over the counter. She gave him the money and he left without incident. I didn’t draw as there wasn’t an imminent threat in my mind. I think I had my hand on my gun or should have.

The second scenario was an armed robbery with a gun. I had my gun drawn and was hiding as others got out of the store. No one was injured, but he came after me. I ended up firing in that scenario and he took off.

Each situation will be different, but thinking and talking about these scenarios can help you think through them in a high stress situation. It’s muscle memory for your brain.

2 Likes

Good stuff Raymond,

Thank you

1 Like

I don’t believe there’s any state in which you would have to legally consider whether or not the person can reach you with the knife. We all know that it takes but a flash of a second for a knife wielding attacker to close the distance.

In that video your actions were perfectly fine but if you had chosen to draw and fire you’d have been just fine legally.

We have to remember that just because we can shoot in a given set of circumstances doesn’t mean we are required to.

2 Likes