What would you do: Run, Hide, or Engage?

We also have to keep in mind that not even body cam’s can give us the same 230-270 degree perspective of the person in the middle of the situation.

Your perspective as a participant will always be limited and slightly different from that of anyone else involved or from the available video evidence.

1 Like

In the situation shown numerous people would have been killed and/or slashed long before police could arrive.

The national average for an emergency code is around 4.5 minutes, five people were slashed and stabbed in about ten seconds in that case.

Intervening in a third party situation always poses a high level of risk and liability on the defender but sometimes it’s absolutely necessary.

Nobody is required to assume those risks and liability which is why we consider those who do to be heroes because they are putting themselves at great risk for others with no expectation or even thought of reward.

1 Like

In a case like this the duty to retreat would I think be waived since the person in danger you are protecting cannot retreat.

1 Like

Think I have seen that kind of question on a police exam. And if I remember right do nothing and be the best witness you can is the ans.

1 Like

One thing Ive learned from the lawyers and the training is that each scenario is different. In this one, we have not ascertained if I have a firearm on me. We did not ascertain if the store I am in had a no firearm sign.
Those two facts can change drastically what our response would be.
In USCCA training they use the shark tank to discuss what is worth using your firearm over. Im not sure Id jump in a shark tank over someone I don’t know. My wife or daughter, yes, but a stranger, not so sure.

1 Like

A police exam for becoming a police officer, @John28? A police officer and a civilian would definitely see the situation differently and have different options for their response.

You’re so right @Jacob2! Every situation is different. I love that you’re applying the shark tank test in your mental training! Mental training is so important!

That’s the thing about polls, they only cover what the polling party want the results to show and there is no option for additional information like you said, Robert5. Hide first to get a better vantage point to engage would have been an ideal option to select on this poll.

1 Like

You don’t really have to worry about the 21’ rule when the bad guy is holding a hostage.

If this is just some nut acting crazy waving a knife around you would but no one is going to make that rush on you before you can draw while holding a hostage.

That’s my thoughts. In this scenario, I would probably get within 15 feet. Any closer, and I believe, I would be in danger. Even with a gun in hand, and aimed, the attacker could get to you, unless you shut down the central nervous system completely. (Head shot)

This is one of those rare situations where I’d say the head shot is the only logical choice and I’d get as close as I felt necessary to guarantee a one shot instantly disabling shot.

1 Like

Very true. But someone taking the exam is a civilian.

Isn’t this more of a human question than a armed citizen question? I pray my courage wouldn’t fail me to get in that shark tank, armed or not.

Hmmm… why would a civilian take a police exam unless they’re becoming a police officer, @John28? Unless there’s something I’m missing, which there very well could be. :thinking:

Yup - the answers to this one are pretty limited. We kept it the same as the Live Training Broadcast verbiage for a reason :wink:

Watch for a bigger variety of responses to polls in the future. :smiley: