Forced entry to home for theft

Kind of a legal question here. I am not sure how this works in other castle doctrine states, but in Wisconsin it appears you can threaten the use of force when protecting property…

“A person is privileged to threaten or intentionally use force against another for the purpose of preventing or terminating what the person reasonably believes to be an unlawful interference with the person’s property. Only such degree of force or threat thereof may intentionally be used as the actor reasonably believes is necessary to prevent or terminate the interference. It is not reasonable to intentionally use force intended or likely to cause death or great bodily harm for the sole purpose of defense of one’s property.

So that last sentence in the paragraph above is the key point. Apparently I can threaten while being robbed, but cannot actually pull the trigger and cause injury unless I am in fear of death or injury myself.

I know the following scenario is a bit of a stretch but bear with me. So hypothetically, let’s say someone wants to rob my house. The dude knocks on my door. I don’t know the man but he seems normal enough and I open the door. Only an easily torn screen door is now between him and me. He then kicks through the screen door and enters. He then surprisingly announces his intent to rob the place and that IF I don’t interfere nobody will get hurt.

So at that point I can stand out of the way and let him have at my belongings (while I call 911), I can go hand to hand, or I can threaten to shoot. Per Wisconsin castle doctrine (above), I make the threat of defense with my hand gun, which was hidden from view but instantly accessible. The dude now comes at me. Am I justified in shooting? Here I assume he does intend bodily harm to me. How bad such injury would have been (or even death) I would not know until after the fact. And I will not allow that option to play out.

Now I could have just walked away (even have gone outside), and called 911. But Wisconsin castle doctrine does allow one to make the threat. If your bluff is called and you therefore fear injury or death, and you shoot, how bad are the impending legal gymnastics?

3 Likes

If someone is willing to coming into your house uninvited when you’re home, how do you know what their intentions are?

If I can get away, I will. If my granddaughter is in the house, I will not leave her.

The idea of leaving my house to someone else is incredibly frustrating. But the idea of shooting someone over stuff and having to deal with the legal ramifications for months, if not years, is even more frustrating.

8 Likes

If your name is not Nadia Comaneci or Simone Biles, Bart Connor or Paul Hamm,


Today’s environment I give you a 2.0

3 Likes

Hi Dawn, I agree that to shoot over just “stuff” is excessive. I was only trying to take the Wisconsin law to the next step (as I wrote: “hypothetically”) when one legally makes the threat of firearm use (in Wisconsin) during a theft. It seems to me that if your life IS then threatened AFTER that, that “normal” self defense rules apply.

Cut and run does seem to be the “preferred” option in almost every scenario these days. Not that I have any sort of “Death Wish”, but this clip seems to pretty much summarize how things are these days.

6 Likes

What’s to understand here. Only shoot if death or great bodily harm. Burglar watches home tries to steal incognito. Someone forces their way in while you’re sleeping or known to be home is not there to have coffee & chat. For me: I only see a couple of problems, drunk wrong house, no knock swat. Just me…

2 Likes

I would think that once he has kicked in your screen door and force himself into your house, wouldn’t you be justified in dropping him right there? At that point he has proven that he is a violent criminal. It doesn’t matter what he says after that, his words can’t be trusted. His initial intention may be to rob, but after the robbery maybe his intentions change into having no witnesses.

2 Likes

It all depends like Dawn said. If you own a ranch style vs. 2 story, where you family members are. If they break into the house in the middle of the night…99% chance my entire family is on the second floor. I have cameras and smart lights on first floor. I would start recording , turn all the lights on and check to insure anyone that is supposed to be in the house is accounted for and upstairs. If they are that is where I stay. In the mean time my wife will have called 911. Of course that is if they are crazy enough to come in since my dog is 120+ pounds. While he is a sweetheart of a dog he is also fiercely protective. If they decide to step foot on the stairs after all that…their foot would not make it past the 2nd because they have clearly showed their intent.

Would be completely different in a single story, especially if bedrooms are on opposite sides of the house or if anyone that should be in the house is down stairs during the break in.

2 Likes

I’ve seen this enough to where I am going to make a statement that I would not normally make.

Read your laws.

  1. What is the difference between a Theft of Property and a Robbery?

  2. What is the difference between a Burglary and a Robbery?

Here’s a hint. It’s the same thing in both cases.

3 Likes

I’m learning quickly that you’re supposed to avoid the area or flee your home, give them what they want or go to jail! This is the new normal. If you can’t abide by mob rules there’re are other ways to keeping your neighborhood safe!


No shooting required!

3 Likes

I don’t think people are understanding the new laws, you have no legal standing to protect yourself in your home. It’s done, over! No matter what the constitution says you are wrong!
Save yourself the legal fees and jump out 2nd floor windows, flee your home avoid the area and only incur the medical costs. Better than going up against any prosecutor or the media in the United States, you have no equal protection under the supposed laws! The Bill of Rights is a myth! Prove me wrong! Only good guys are being charged and flaunted in the media!

1 Like

@Scott52 Nope, that’s no good either it’s too intimidating.

And before you say it, I’ve already looked into digging traps with spikes in the yard and apparently that’s illegal too… i can’t even set up a simple sentry gun aimed down the main entranceway of my home!
For crying out loud!

The truth is, that little boy in “home alone” was the REAL criminal.

2 Likes